Methods to categorise ‘skinny’ & ‘thick’ IoT edge deployments


Edge platforms proceed to play an important position within the Web of Issues (IoT) ecosystem. Companies deploying IoT options recognise that many optimally designed IoT options, particularly these within the industrial vertical, reap the benefits of one or a number of edge parts, says Josh Taubenheim, IoT know-how analyst at MachNation.

The truth is, MachNation analysis means that 85% of IoT options in verticals corresponding to manufacturing, industrial transportation, constructing automation, and logistics will probably be required to leverage edge computing to fulfill enterprise and operational necessities.

We spend a variety of time serving to enterprises architect their edge options after which determine IoT platform distributors that may appropriately assist these enterprises’ IIoT architectures. That is no small feat for 2 causes. First, nearly all edge options are integrated into brownfield options. And second, there are lots of IoT platforms that assist edge, nonetheless, not all of them do it effectively.

Let’s have a look at the variations between skinny and thick edge after which present some ideas about related IoT platform distributors that assist edge deployments.

Skinny vs. thick edge

The complexity and implementation of edge applied sciences can differ broadly. An enterprise’s IoT use-case determines the sting {hardware} necessities. In keeping with MachNation analysis of enterprise IoT consumers, roughly 90% of the complexity on the edge is software-related. Thus, whereas many {hardware} distributors already present {hardware} that adequately helps most IoT options, the standard, sophistication, usability, and scalability of distributors’ software program and platform for each thin- and thick-edge deployments stay a differentiator.

What’s the distinction between thin-edge and thick-edge? 

Skinny-edge: MachNation defines a skinny edge as an IoT answer supporting and managing decentralised deployments of low-powered, reminiscence and energy constrained units, examples of which embrace Arm Cortex-M units, low-power Texas Devices (TI) units, Marvell Expertise units, and others. 

These units transmit information northbound with minimal execution of workloads (e.g., filtering, aggregation, or normalisation) or analytics being carried out on the website of knowledge origin. Enterprises set up skinny edge nodes to attach legacy gear to their cloud options, thereby benefiting from price financial savings on gear. 

Typical thin-edge use circumstances embrace: 

  1. Geographical asset monitoring; low-powered, steady transmission to cloud 
  2. Predictive machine upkeep; information factors on machine well being, monitoring
  3. Good metropolis / constructing; distributed {hardware} on a centralised community transmitting focused information factors

Thick-edge: MachNation defines thick edge as an IoT answer supporting and managing high-powered, high-capability edge {hardware}, examples of which embrace high-powered IoT gateway units from firms like Dell and Cisco, Arm Cortex-A units, x.86-based units, and others. 

These units can run superior on-device inference, occasion processing guidelines, enterprise logic, analytics, and machine studying algorithms.

Typical thick-edge use circumstances embrace:

  1. Superior machine upkeep; on-device anomaly detection, analytics, and parameter-defined occasion processing actions
  2. Automation; native logic execution, on-device analytics, information normalisation
  3. Cloud optimisation: lowering cloud-overhead by performing information administration features on-device (e.g. filtering out “junk” information earlier than transmitting to the cloud)

MachNation’s analysis of IoT edge platforms

For the fifth 12 months, MachNation has revealed its IoT Edge ScoreCard to help enterprise, system integrator (SI), and repair supplier (SP) consumers of their analysis processes and to supply pointers for a very powerful edge traits. We’ve performed these analyses because of the nice variety within the high quality of edge platforms and the technological heritage of the assorted platform distributors.

MachNation’s 2022 IoT Edge ScoreCard charges distributors towards the necessities of best-in-class software program, {hardware}, and hybrid approaches to edge. MachNation recognises that at present’s edge vendor panorama is each nascent and vibrant – providing myriad viable worth propositions. As such, MachNation felt it necessary to incorporate distributors that supply software-focused, hardware-focused, and hybrid choices on this ScoreCard.

MachNation rated 12 IoT edge distributors throughout a set of necessities spanning 4 classes. The 4 classes of necessities include 19 sub-requirements which can be the underlying bases of MachNation’s score. The 4 classes are:

Edge information processing – IoT edge platforms ought to exhibit sturdy information processing capabilities. MachNation evaluates the robustness of IoT edge platforms on 5 key sub-requirements: information ingestion mannequin, information normalisation methods, information storage flexibility, guidelines engine sophistication, and analytics and visualisation capabilities. Edge platforms ought to have the power to ingest information by providing in depth assist for southbound legacy protocols (e.g., Modbus and PROFIBUS over RS-232) and up to date protocols (e.g., PROFINET over Ethernet). An edge platform ought to allow distant configuration and administration of data-normalisation features, together with the power to use statistical features and customized algorithms to ingested machine information. As well as, an edge platform ought to present a versatile information retailer and an occasion processor that may deal with easy guidelines by way of declarative configuration and complicated guidelines by way of scripting logic or customized code. 

Edge administration – IoT edge platform distributors ought to construct their platforms with refined edge administration capabilities. Edge administration sophistication is demonstrated when distributors deal with offering excellence in 5 key sub necessities: distant configuration, distant software program administration, connectivity administration, deployment, and autonomy. The platform ought to have a set of options that empower an operations know-how (OT) person to simply handle an IoT deployment.

Structure and integration – MachNation believes that the very best IoT edge know-how ought to exhibit a cogent structure with sturdy integration capabilities. Platform microservices ought to be constructed with each developer and person in thoughts. Integrations – pre-built connections to exterior enterprise techniques and purposes are present in just about each IoT answer and thus present vital worth for ease of deployment and manageability. When evaluating the cogency of the structure and the mixing mannequin, there are 5 sub-requirements MachNation evaluates: a safety mannequin; versatile cloud and native integration; platform productisation; a dwell edge market; and the general developer expertise. 

Technique and enterprise – Finest positioned IoT edge distributors may have a well-developed, appropriately sized enterprise and a sound IoT technique. All different issues equal, a profitable IoT edge vendor may have in depth monetary and human assets to assist edge growth and gross sales efforts; understanding of key IoT developments and buyer wants; and a cogent, centered, and forward-thinking enterprise imaginative and prescient that relates on to the geographic market, buyer segments, and business sectors served by the sting vendor. 

A IoT edge platform vendor excels in every of MachNation’s 4 analysis classes with explicit emphasis on offering distinctive know-how, a refined person expertise (UX), and robust documentation.

MachNation’s 2022 IoT Edge ScoreCard contains the next distributors (listed alphabetically): ADLINK, Amazon, IoT.nxt, Eurotech, HPE, Losant, Microsoft, Pelion, ThingsBoard, Siemens, Software program AG, and ZEDEDA. MachNation chosen a gaggle of taking part distributors that adequately signify the range of approaches and sizes on this burgeoning IoT edge market. MachNation’s analysis and testing crew chooses contributors that present a mixture of approaches for thin- and thick-edge options.


To summarise, the excellence between “skinny” and “thick” edge boils all the way down to the place the info processing happens and the place actionable intelligence is generated. Each IoT edge deployment ought to be purpose-built to suit the use case. Restrictions on accessible {hardware} and software program will also be figuring out elements. It’s the advice of MachNation to have a well-defined {hardware} and software program technique in place earlier than embarking on an IoT edge journey. 

Selecting an IoT edge vendor comes all the way down to a number of elements:

  • Use-case
  • {Hardware} availability
  • Cloud infrastructure to assist your edge answer
  • Necessities round information latency, and different on-device compute assets

MachNation recognises the significance of edge know-how within the IoT business. Due to that we’ve got chosen to dedicate an annual examine of IoT edge distributors that supply edge options.

The writer is Josh Taubenheim, IoT know-how analyst at MachNation.

Touch upon this text under or by way of Twitter: @IoTNow_OR @jcIoTnow