Apple wins VirnetX patent enchantment — however one verdict awaits


VirnetX trial

AppleInsider might earn an affiliate fee on purchases made by way of hyperlinks on our website.

Apple has been battling VirnetX in courtroom for over a decade over patents, and on Thursday, the US Courtroom of Appeals handed Apple a victory within the newest skirmish.

In 2010, VirnetX launched a authorized dispute by alleging quite a few cases of patent infringement associated to FaceTime, VPN, and iMessage providers. A Texas courtroom fined Apple $368 million in 2012 for violating one patent, however the ruling was overturned virtually two years later.

In the latest replace, Apple satisfied the US Courtroom of Appeals for the Federal Circuit to invalidate the 2 patents by upholding a choice from the USPTO’s Patent Trial and Enchantment Board, in response to Reuters.

It would overturn the $502 million high quality that Apple was ordered to pay in 2020. The corporate individually appealed that verdict, however the Federal Circuit nonetheless has to rule in that case.

“If the courtroom upholds the [USPTO’s] determination, we now have an enormous downside,” VirnetX lawyer Jeff Lamken of MoloLamken stated on the September listening to. “I do not suppose we now have an enforceable judgment.”

The case has gone by way of quite a few appeals and rulings. With the Federal Circuit’s determination on Thursday, Apple and VirnetX await a remaining determination in Apple’s enchantment of the preliminary verdict out of East Texas.

VirnetX had individually received a $302 million verdict in opposition to Apple in 2016, which was elevated to $440 million in a while.